LEGO Halloween Hayride 40423-1
LEGO Halloween Hayride (40423-1) is worth about $52 on the secondary market today, against a $16 retail price. It has 148 pieces, belongs to the Seasonal theme and was released in 2020. This set has retired — LEGO no longer produces it, so supply is fixed and prices are set entirely by the resale market.
Fun, buildable Halloween scene for play and display!
- Set number
- 40423-1
- Theme
- Seasonal
- Subtheme
- Halloween
- Year
- 2020
- Pieces
- 148
- Minifigures
- 3
- RRP
- $16
- Market value
- $52
- Used value
- $22
- Released
- 2020
- Retirement
- Retired in 2021
Minifigures in LEGO Halloween Hayride
Halloween Hayride value by year
From $12 in 2018 to $24 in 2026 so far: +106%. Its highest year was 2025, at $25.
| Year | Value | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 (so far) | $24 | −1.9% |
| 2025 | $25 | +8.3% |
| 2024 | $23 | +22.7% |
| 2023 | $18 | +18.3% |
| 2022 | $16 | +5.7% |
| 2021 | $15 | −9.9% |
| 2020 | $16 | +40.1% |
| 2019 | $12 | +0.0% |
| 2018 | $12 | — |
Median of each year's market prices, sealed, in US dollars.
What you are paying for
Its 3 priced minifigures are worth about $7 together, roughly 14% of the set's value — about typical for sets with minifigures (typically 24%).
Frequently asked questions
How much is LEGO Halloween Hayride (40423-1) worth?
LEGO Halloween Hayride is worth approximately $52 on the secondary market today, based on current listings and completed sales. BrickStats updates this value daily.
Is LEGO Halloween Hayride retired?
Yes — Halloween Hayride (40423-1) has been retired by LEGO and is no longer in production. Retired sets have fixed supply, which is why their prices are driven purely by the resale market.
Has LEGO Halloween Hayride gone up in value?
Yes. Halloween Hayride launched at $16 and now trades around $52, an increase of 224.9%. See the price history chart for how it got there.
What is the price per piece for Halloween Hayride?
At its $16 retail price across 148 pieces, Halloween Hayride works out to about $0.108 per piece. Collectors often use price per piece to judge whether a set is good value.
Is LEGO Halloween Hayride a good investment?
Halloween Hayride currently trades 224.9% above its $16 retail price, and it is retired, so no new supply is entering the market. Past performance is not a prediction — condition, packaging and how long you hold all affect what a set actually sells for. BrickStats reports the numbers rather than giving investment advice.
Why is LEGO Halloween Hayride so expensive?
Halloween Hayride was released in 2020 and has since retired. Once LEGO stops producing a set, the only supply is what is already in circulation, so sealed copies in good condition compete for a shrinking pool of stock. That scarcity, not the parts, is what moves the price.